What Makes This Hotel Stand Out
Its vibrant Tiki bar atmosphere, complimentary bike rentals, and direct beachfront access create a fun and convenient base for exploring the Florida Keys.
Parent Pro Tip
Book a suite for ample space and separation for kids' sleeping areas, and confirm any specific room requests directly with the hotel prior to arrival to avoid potential issues.
“Our favorite parts were the location of the hotel, room balcony, access to the bikes, the rum runner water taxi, the pool and the tiki bar”
“Amazing time with our 3 kids (all under 5 years old). 1 bedroom suite was beautiful, spacious, and the bedroom portion had no balcony or windows...”
“We had the best time. The weather wasn’t great which was expected in August but it didn’t matter. Jackie and Marcus were fun , attentive and friendly.”
“The beach area had corn hole and lots of other yard games. We had so much fun fishing for many hours a day”
“The pool was very busy on Saturday but all other days there were ample chairs. The shuttle was a nice extra with Fabian providing excellent service.”
Families love Amara Cay for its beachfront access, fun pool, and bike rentals. The spacious suites and helpful staff make stays comfortable and memorable. Offers great value for Keys getaways.
Amara Cay Resort offers a family-friendly experience with its beautiful beachfront setting, excellent pool, and engaging activities like biking and water sports. While most families have positive stays, potential guests should be aware of occasional inconsistencies in room maintenance and service.
Best for: Ideal for active families looking for a relaxed Keys vacation with a focus on water activities and outdoor enjoyment.
Offers good value for a Florida Keys resort, especially with suite options and included amenities like bikes and shuttle...
The resort offers suites, which are ideal for families, with separate bedroom areas and pull-out sofas providing flexible sleeping arrangements.
The resort boasts a beautiful and heated outdoor pool, which is a major draw for families.
The on-site restaurant receives mixed reviews, with some finding it good and others limited.
Amara Cay Resort is well-positioned in Islamorada, offering convenient access to local restaurants and attractions via bike or the resort's shuttle service.
80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036-3802
The resort offers many active pursuits and a great pool, which are more suited to toddlers and older children. Infant amenities like cribs are available, but the beach access and overall atmosphere might be less ideal for very young babies.
Our AI has analyzed 50 family reviews to give you detailed insights about what makes this hotel great for families.
Amara Cay Resort offers a family-friendly experience with its beautiful beachfront setting, excellent pool, and engaging activities like biking and water sports. While most families have positive stays, potential guests should be aware of occasional inconsistencies in room maintenance and service.
The resort offers suites, which are ideal for families, with separate bedroom areas and pull-out sofas providing flexible sleeping arrangements. Some suites have balconies in the living room area, offering outdoor space for families to enjoy. The layout of some one-bedroom suites is particularly noted as being great for young children's sleep.
The resort boasts a beautiful and heated outdoor pool, which is a major draw for families. While there isn't a dedicated kids' club or playground mentioned, the availability of bikes, board games, and water activities like canoeing and snorkeling caters to active children.
The on-site restaurant receives mixed reviews, with some finding it good and others limited. Families can also utilize options like room service or easily access dining by biking or using the shuttle. Kids' meals are available, and the option for breakfast in the room is a convenient perk.
Cleanliness is generally praised, with rooms described as spotless and grounds immaculate. However, a few negative reviews mention issues like noticeable odors in rooms, chips under beds, and damaged cabinets, indicating inconsistent housekeeping in some instances.
Amara Cay Resort is well-positioned in Islamorada, offering convenient access to local restaurants and attractions via bike or the resort's shuttle service. Its beachfront location allows for easy enjoyment of the water and nearby activities.
Check-in experiences have been varied, with some guests encountering delays or issues with room assignments. While staff are frequently praised for helpfulness and kindness, there are also mentions of rudeness or unresponsiveness in some negative reviews. Parking is available, including paid private parking.
Some guests have reported issues with the condition of rooms, including tired furnishings, noisy AC units, and uncomfortable sofa beds. The beach is described by some as not a 'natural beach' and requires steps to access the water, which could be a concern for families with very young children or those with mobility issues.
Browse more family hotels by amenity
Explore other top-rated family-friendly hotels nearby
Families love La Jolla Resort for its spacious suites, free water sports equipment, and prime location near restaurants. The friendly staff and beautiful beachfront make it a memorable getaway.
Based on 50 reviews (7 family reviews)
Ragged Edge Resort shines for families with its immaculate rooms, beachfront access, and a strong emphasis on relaxation. It offers excellent value with kitchenettes and a laid-back atmosphere perfect for making lasting family memories.
Based on 50 reviews (12 family reviews)
Families rave about this resort's beautiful grounds, family-friendly activities like mini-golf and kayaking, comfortable rooms, and helpful staff. It's a tropical paradise offering relaxation and fun.
Based on 50 reviews (16 family reviews)
Families enjoy Cheeca Lodge for its beautiful grounds, fantastic pools, kids' activities like Camp Cheeca, and attentive staff. The beachfront location and numerous amenities make it a relaxing escape.
Based on 50 reviews (16 family reviews)
Families rave about Pines and Palms Resort for its beachfront access, complimentary water sports like kayaking and paddleboarding, and a relaxed, boutique atmosphere. The recently renovated rooms and attentive staff make it a top choice for a Keys getaway.
Based on 50 reviews (9 family reviews)
Families appreciate the clean, updated rooms, convenient kitchenette, and pleasant waterfront location. The outdoor pool and hot tubs offer family fun, and many reviewers praise the welcoming atmosphere.
Based on 50 reviews (14 family reviews)
AI summaries and family ratings are generated by Hotels for Families. Always verify details directly with hotels before booking.